Under-25s could lose access to Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and the health element of Universal Credit under major welfare reforms proposed by Alan Milburn.
The former Labour Cabinet minister wants to replace the existing system with a new Youth Allowance as part of a £5.8billion plan to tackle Britain's youth unemployment crisis, warning some young people will be financially worse off.
His Government-commissioned report comes after the number of 16 to 24-year-olds not in education, employment or training (Neet) passed one million earlier this year for the first time in more than a decade.
Under the proposals, disabled young people would receive alternative support, including an Additional Costs Allowance to help cover disability-related expenses, a local Health and Disability Fund for specific costs such as equipment and travel, and a higher-rate benefit for those with severe and complex needs who will never be able to work.
However, some young people could receive less than they currently get through PIP and Universal Credit.
Mr Milburn said welfare reform was a "litmus test" for Labour and insisted MPs "have to vote for it".
"There will be some young people who are worse off, at least initially, as a consequence of benefit changes, but in the end, the best thing for people is to get them into work," he told Sky News.
His 10-year plan would involve around £5.8billion in annual funding by 2036-37, offset by £3.6billion in welfare savings and £2.4billion in additional tax revenue from people in work.
The main recommendations include:
- New Youth Allowance: Under-25s would move off the existing Universal Credit system, including its health element.
- PIP replacement: A new Additional Costs Allowance would help disabled young people meet extra costs associated with their conditions.
- Health and Disability Fund: Local funding would help cover specific expenses, including equipment and travel to job interviews or training.
- Higher payments for severe disabilities: A higher-rate benefit would support young people with severe and complex needs who will never be able to work.
- National Insurance cuts: Employers would gradually pay less National Insurance for workers under 25, initially in retail and hospitality.
- Work and training guarantee: Young people would be offered employment, training or education opportunities, with those refusing an offer potentially facing benefit cuts.
- More personalised support: A new youth opportunity service would provide named advisers and tailored plans covering employment, careers and health.
- More apprenticeships: The number of young people completing apprenticeships would be doubled over the next decade.
Some young people could receive less financial support than they currently get through PIP and Universal Credit, despite the proposed replacement payments and additional funds.
Responding to Alan Milburn’s proposed changes to tackle high youth unemployment, Kelly Nicoll CFIOSH, Immediate Past President at Institution of Occupational Safety and Health, said: “One of the most significant aspects of the Milburn Review is its recognition that young people’s mental health, wellbeing and employment opportunities are closely connected.
“At the Institution of Occupational Safety and Health, our research found that 61% of young workers have experienced stress at work, while more than a quarter have considered leaving a role because of concerns around wellbeing, support or treatment.
“Supporting more young people into employment is important, but support should not stop once someone secures a job. Good work can play a positive role in building confidence, wellbeing and long-term opportunities, particularly for young people who may face additional barriers to employment.
“Alongside employment and mental health support services, employers have an important role to play in creating working environments where young people feel supported, valued and able to raise concerns. That will be essential if we want young people not only to access work, but to remain in work and thrive.”
Dr Heidi Phillips, specialist GP in neurodiversity at healthcare provider Clinical Partners, insists young people with anxiety, depression, ADHD and autism should be helped into education, training or work.
She said: “ADHD, autism, anxiety and depression can all cause significant functional impairment, and people will be affected very differently. What matters is understanding what is getting in the way for that individual and putting the right support around them.
“For some people that may be treatment or other healthcare support. For others it may be flexibility or relatively simple adjustments in the workplace. The aim should be to help young people into education, training or work that they can actually sustain, rather than simply moving them off benefits.
“If we get that right, the benefits to the individual come first, and the economic benefits should follow.”
The report aims to halve the Neet rate from 13% to around 5% by 2036, potentially bringing 600,000 more young people into education, employment or training each year.
However, disability campaigners have raised concerns about the impact of removing existing financial support.
Harriet Edwards, from disability charity Sense, said: "We share Alan Milburn's ambition to break down the barriers that prevent young disabled people who want to work from doing so."
She added: "We urge the Government to provide urgent reassurance that no young disabled person with complex needs will be left worse off."
Victoria Oliver, Partner and Head of Spinal Injury at Bolt Burdon Kemp , also questioned whether the proposals would adequately address the practical barriers disabled young people face.
What should you look out for in today's Milburn Review report? We lay out the essential facts about recent trends in youth education, employment and benefit claims, and suggest the key questions to ask of the Review once it's out, in our comment below ⬇️ https://t.co/2DpY6yXx9r
— Institute for Fiscal Studies (@TheIFS) November 17, 2026
She said: "Whilst it is positive to see talk of increasing employment support for young people through placement, subsidies and one-to-one advisors, as the Milburn report is expected to recommend, my concern is that it does not go far enough to specifically address the more practical challenges that young people with disabilities face when trying to work."
She warned: "Opportunities are worthless if they take place at inaccessible offices or if businesses aren’t prepared to consider part time or flexible working."
Ms Oliver also highlighted problems with the Access to Work scheme, which provides practical and financial support for disabled people in employment.
She said: "Unacceptable delays in processing applications is undermining its effectiveness. Workers who have disabilities are being forced to choose between risking their jobs and risking their health by working without appropriate adjustments."
Recommended reading:
- Calls are growing to halt Government State Pension age rise to 68
- Should you leave your heating on all day? Martin Lewis has shared his verdict
- Workers over 21 given £910 cash boost confirms Andy Burnham
Transport accessibility is another major concern. Ms Oliver cited research suggesting almost half of disabled professionals had turned down job opportunities because of transport issues, while nearly 90% of young disabled people reported difficulties travelling.
She said: "Disabled people, especially young disabled people, need more than opportunities; they need guarantees of a better future."
The report also recommends gradually reducing employers' National Insurance contributions for under-25s, initially in retail and hospitality, alongside a legal guarantee of work, training or employment support. Those refusing an offer could potentially lose benefits.
Share